A Plague on the Warren-Sanders Kerfuffle

Elizabeth Warren Bernie SandersDon Rose

With impeachment proceedings about to begin there are more significant things to discuss than the media-inflated battle between Elizabeth Warren and Bernie Sanders over whether he told her privately back in 2018 that a woman could not be elected president. Unfortunately it’s causing much consternation in progressive circles and much glee among their moderate competitors.

Sanders denies he said it—she insists he did. One of them is lying, or at best fails to recognize a possible nuance in the statement. I like them both and have no idea who said what, but here is what I believe:

A woman clearly can be elected prez—but based on history involving much of the misogyny we have seen in the electorate, it is a legitimate question that many men and women consider, debate and reach differing conclusions. If one believes it will be difficult, if not impossible, for a woman to win, it does not make one a sexist pig. The issue is how one deals with the conclusion.

Let’s assume for a moment that Bernie actually said it back then. There is no evidence whatsoever that he or his minions have repeated it publicly or otherwise used the idea to discourage people from supporting Warren or any other woman. Therefore I think it was a cheap shot on Warren’s part to bring it up now to use against him. In the long run I fear it will hurt her more than him, at a time it is much more urgent to determine whether a progressive populist can get nominated and beat Donald J. Trump.

If he did not actually say it, I would be bitterly disappointed in Warren–a candidate I have felt close to for months. But we probably will never learn the truth.

As we have seen over and over, identity is not the driving issue in this campaign. Beating Trump is.

Women have not coalesced around any woman candidate, while two who made strong feminist pitches—Kamala Harris and Kirsten Gillibrand—were early dropouts. African American candidates failed to win significant black votes while Joe Biden—viewed as more likely to beat Trump—draws nearly half the AA voters and Sanders gets the next largest share. So too with Latinx.

Some might ask whether a professed socialist can win. If you don’t think so, that does not necessarily make you a McCarthyite. If Buttigieg makes a strong showing in Iowa some folks will surely debate whether a gay man can be elected—and that does not necessarily make them homophobes. They are unanswerable questions until history answers them.

Remember–a Catholic couldn’t be elected until JFK did. Needless to say many of us didn’t think an African American could until 48 years later.

Back to the Sanders-Warren scuffle, the upshot of this needless fight is it will be harder for the two to come together in a progressive alliance even without further attacks on each other. They both have the resources to continue and if neither is blown away in early primaries, a contested convention becomes more likely—which helps Biden.

2 thoughts on “A Plague on the Warren-Sanders Kerfuffle

  1. Actually, a woman was elected in 2016. Per the national popular vote, at least. That many despise what that particular woman “stands for” (Yuppie self-aggrandizement and the continuation of [Big] Business As Usual), including myself, did not stop that popular vote victory. (I voted for a different woman, Dr. Jill Stein, for the record.) The last Establishment POTUS candidate I voted for was Obama, in his first run. I voted while disbelieving that he could actually win. So, as Trump has announced the precedent of actually participating in the anti-choice march coming up (previous GOP presidents have settled for addressing rallies by remote video), we have to ask rhetorically: will enough potential women voters wake up to the need to replace Emperor Trump come November and get to the voting places? My gut right now tells me the Dem. Party Establishment will warm up to Sen. Klobuchar (“Oh, she’s so delightfully sensible!” they’ll swoon!)…if they come to realize how unappealing tired old Joe Biden really is.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s