Fake News is a Lie

Trump Hitler

Stuart Lyle

In the era of information overload, it is essential to distinguish between what is misleadingly called “fake news,” and a downright lie.  They sound related, but they are not synonymous.  In fact, the relationship between the two is more complex, since calling valid reporting, i.e. “news,” fake is a lie itself.

A lie is a deliberate misrepresentation of reality, of the truth. A lie is when a government says one thing… but then does the opposite.  A lie is when a politician “gins up” the threat to sacred “national security” to justify an otherwise unjustifiable military adventure.  The Bush administration, with the help of the UK’s Blair government, did just that to corral public opinion into supporting their war on Iraq.

Lies not only misrepresent, but also distort reality. The Nazis and the Soviets both understood the effectiveness of a good lie…

If you tell a lie big enough and keep repeating it, people will eventually come to believe it. The lie can be maintained only for such time as the State can shield the people from the political, economic and/or military consequences of the lie. It thus becomes vitally important for the State to use all of its powers to repress dissent, for the truth is the mortal enemy of the lie, and thus by extension, the truth is the greatest enemy of the State.

Joseph Goebbels

The Guardian carried this message about Soviet lies from a Warsaw ghetto survivor:

Do not underestimate the destructive power of lies. When the war broke out in 1939, my family fled east and settled for a couple of years in Soviet-occupied Lwów (now Lviv in western Ukraine). The city was full of refugees, and rumours were swirling about mass deportations to gulags in Siberia and Kazakhstan. To calm the situation, a Soviet official gave a speech declaring that the rumours were false – nowadays they would be called “fake news” – and that anyone spreading them would be arrested. Two days later, the deportations to the gulags began, with thousands sent to their deaths.

Lies are what build and protect the power of a dictatorship.  Those lies are fashioned for easy consumption by fearful citizens. When the US President said that there was an ‘imminent threat’ from Iranian general Qassem Soleimani, he was lying, but we hardly noticed in the avalanche of lies from the White House.  The Washington Post has meticulously counted the lies since the last inauguration, all 16,000+ of them.

One of the most insidious lies, perhaps this is the “big lie” of the current era, is to label legitimate news as ‘fake.’  It is a very carefully formulated lie. It is designed to both undermine public confidence the veracity of the news, while simultaneously setting the stage for a new lie, one that directly counters the true facts.

In an ever-changing, incomprehensible world the masses [would] reach the point where they would, at the same time, believe everything and nothing, think that everything was possible and that nothing was true.

Hannah Arendt, Origins of Totalitarianism

It is surprisingly easy to shrug off inconvenient information as ‘fake.’  After all, if what you are being told is somehow fake, then why take the time to understand the research, analysis and thought that went into that news?  If, as the White House claimed, the Impeachment was a witch hunt – here ‘witch hunt’ is a synonym for ‘fake’ – then it is not worth bothering to understand any of the compelling evidence that emerged in the House of Representatives.

Calling legitimate news ‘fake’ is a very dangerous lie.  It comes as American democracy is on the ropes.  If it survives this bout, it will be a very reduced version of the robust democracy that has thrived and struggled over 200 years.  It’s a lie to believe anything else.

9 thoughts on “Fake News is a Lie

  1. I recently dusted off my DVD of Leni Riefenstahl’s film of the September 1934 Nazi Party celebrations in Nuremberg, “Triumph of the Will.” I now believe this film is essential viewing for anyone wishing to really understand what Trump and his backers are engaging in today. The accompanying running commentary track by historian Anthony Santoro is very instructive. [This DVD is the Synapse Films version, copyright 2001.] The degree of reorganization of German society since Hitler had become Chancellor in early 1933 is astounding. In terms of calling themselves a brand of “socialism”–and, in German, the name of the party even included the phrase “Workers’ Party”!–“national socialism,” as we know it, the Nazis actually “promised” a united society (nation) “without class or caste distinctions.” As if they liquidated their industrialist millionaires, or assigned them manual labor a la Mao’s “Cultural Revolution”!! Talk about The Big Lie, right? Now, I am not suggesting that Trump has reorganized our society in like manner. He has God knows how many fanatically racist supporters who WOULD pour into the streets, assault rifles in hand, if “something happened” to remove their fuhrer from office, but there is no nationally organized army of Brownshirts. Not yet, at least! But the Trump campaign to render language thoroughly perverted, likely learned from Steve Bannon–think Ministry of Truth in “1984,” and Orwell is brilliant in this sphere–has definite roots in Dr. Goebbels’s machinations. “L’etat, c’est moi” famously proclaimed France’s Louis XIV. The Nazis declared Hitler as indistinguishable from the German nation and state, as well. Does anyone doubt that Trump now considers himself “America,” and anyone questioning this is to be branded a “traitor”?? “Thou shalt not attempt to impeach the very nation itself” is the essence of the stance the GOP members of the United States Senate assumed last week.

  2. It is unlikely that the pomegranate potentate occupying the Executive Office, who regularly yells falsehoods through rotor roar, ever picked up and tried to read Origins of Totalitarianism, 1984, or anything by Goebbels. And even less likely he’d be able to decipher the vocabulary within unless an aid helped him sentence by sentence. This is not a hindrance to the unquenchable yearning of Individual One, of course. As his days in office relentlessly pile up, he demonstrates in exponentially increasing scale he was born quite completely equipped with the innate tools of totalitarianism.

    • Of course the “L’etat, c’est moi” notion is a function of ego and narcissism on Trump’s part. But I’ve seen far too much commentary in the media on aspects of his personality compared to commentary on the genuine damage he’s already done to our society. And bless those GOP Senators, his governmental enablers–it’s all 100% A-OK by them…with the glaring exception of a certain chap from Utah.

  3. One of the greatest fallibilities of fallible human beings is our gullibility: the ease with which many of us can be conned and deluded. Trump is a master at the game, and he must be called out immediately, vigorously and repeatedly each and every time he lies and dissembles, or truth will become even more irrelevant than it has already become.

    • I think it’s pretty clear that the Trump base couldn’t give less of a hoot about truth vs. pure fiction. Their idol spews utter nonsense and they gobble it up unquestioningly. And joyfully!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s