American culture’s long, passionate relationship with violence


Nick Turse.  Courtesy of

[Editor’s Note: In his recent address to the nation, President Obama expressed his belief in the U.S. as an exceptional nation. Inherent to that belief is the idea the U.S. is a shining city on a hill, a moral exemplar to the world, a beacon of freedom, a nation whose people are uniquely qualified to lead.  A chosen people, if you will.  But along with that belief comes a harsh reality of pervasive and endemic violence that began even before our nation was founded, as Nick Turse recounts today in a stunning introduction to Ira Chernus’ provocative article at]

Nick Turse on Violence in America

In the muddled midst of last week’s mass killing in San Bernardino, California, a few words skittering across my Twitter feed gave me pause. “On this awful shooting: Is U.S. culture evil? Enemy of our civilization? Must all Americans apologize? Should we bar U.S. tourists as dangerous?” asked Simon Kuper, a columnist with the Financial Times.

As information about the massacre was dribbling out, Kuper was surely making a larger point, but I got stuck on that word “evil” and thoughts about American culture’s long, passionate relationship with violence. This is well-worn territory, of course, addressed in great depth and with much skill by many thinkers over the years. But whether we’re ruminating on all-American mass killings or slaughter by foreign terrorists, it’s worth recalling that America was incubated in a roiling storm of atrocity and birthed in savage cruelty.

Just two years after the first Thanksgiving, in fact, Pilgrim commander Myles Standish was hacking the head off a Native American chief to be displayed on a pike in front of the fort at Plymouth, Massachusetts. Not so long after, in present day Jersey City, New Jersey, settler soldiers fell upon a group of mostly women and children of the Wappinger tribe. Thirty were tortured to death for “public amusement.” About 80 others were decapitated and their heads carried across the river to present-day Manhattan where they were gleefully kicked about the streets of the town.

Fast-forward to 1779 and the father of this country, George Washington, was dispatching troops to devastate Iroquois settlements in New York and Pennsylvania. A couple of infant America’s slain enemies were then skinned and turned into footwear. The better part of a century later, native blood was still being spilled in savage fashion. At Sand Creek, Colorado, U.S. forces massacred hundreds, scalping old women, killing babies, even violating the dead body of a “comely young squaw.” Soldiers collected penises of the men, sliced off the breasts of the women. One soldier even wore a breast as a cap.

This is not to say that Native Americans didn’t commit horrendous atrocities, only that violence is intricately woven into America’s DNA, a winding helix of cruelty that then threaded its way through the Philippines and the Caribbean, through Hiroshima, No Gun Ri, and My Lai, through Haditha and Kunduz. Where this country went, so went implements of bodily destruction, weaponry designed to kill or maim: rifles and landmines, bombs and missiles. So, too, went cruelty and massacre, rape and torture, horrendous acts as bad as or worse than any imaginable depredations by an “evil” terror group. At home, of course, Americans slaughter each other with frightening regularity in schools and movie theaters and, most recently, a center that offers services to people with developmental disabilities. And this is to say nothing of the other lethal and non-lethal horrors we Americans frequently visit upon each other.

Are these acts evil? Are they committed by evil-doers? What about our Islamic State (IS) enemies who are still decapitating people as did our American forebears (and as our current anti-IS Saudi allies do once every few days)? Is their brand of violence especially atrocious? Have they renounced their humanity by committing such depraved acts? Did we? Is IS so evil that we should fight them for that reason alone?

This is precisely the harsh terrain that TomDispatch regular Ira Chernus navigates today. Analyzing their fundamentalism and ours, he delves into essential questions about good and evil, humanity and its loss.

We live in an age in which America has called out an Axis of Evil, killed the most wanted evildoer on the planet, and relentlessly hunted his minions and spiritual descendants. And what do we have to show for it? Before the next American war and the next American massacre — you can surely count on both — join Chernus in considering the startling costs of America’s seemingly endless (and fruitless) battle with evil.

Copyright Nick Turse 2015.

6 thoughts on “American culture’s long, passionate relationship with violence

  1. First, TomDispatch is a great resource for information and points of view that are usually more cogent and incisive than the dribble in our national mainstream media which both shields and props up the two sole wayward political parties. There is confusion in this article because American relationship to violence is not particular to America because violence transcends nationality to the human race which is violent. Dictators have killed tens millions of people across the world in the 20th Century.

    Also this article focuses on discrete points which in the end are not pivotal, what is pivotal are the particular policies and agendas masked as national interest promoted by our two political parties leading the nation astray. There are rarely alternative points of view in our mainstream media, especially TV network “news”, with powerful facts and information to alter these policies. The American people are fed national propaganda everyday by our “public airwaves.” They omit facts and information that challenge our government’s one-sided policies. A democracy is only as strong and vital as the facts and information provided to the people.

    • Agreed, Henry. And I think that’s Nick’s point about our violent record: it is precisely because we are unexceptional in our violent past that makes it ludicrous to argue we are exceptional in our values and how we practice them.

  2. Really? Everybody thinks America is so special, even in their violence are they the most special ones? This text describes atrocities against indigenous people something like 200 years ago. Well, what about violence exhibited by Chinese, Egyptians, Saxons, Alemanns, and so on, thousands of years ago? What exactly makes Northern America so special?

    • Nothing. And I think that’s the point of Turse’s article. We are not exceptional. We are not special. We are violent — just like so many other peoples throughout history. Yet we are at pains to deny this violent past — at least to ourselves. And that denial is dangerous.

  3. This discussion could go on until the end of time (for humanity, and the clock is ticking, thanks to the violence perpetrated against the environment). “Violence is as American as cherry pie.” Did anyone ever say it so plainly and effectively as H. Rap Brown?!? In my view the salient points are: 1.) the escalation from the violence of clashes between neighboring tribes in pre-history to the highly organized violence perpetrated by the state [folks, you really should read Marx/Engels and V.I. Lenin on these issues!] in defense of the interests of its ruling elite; and 2.) the nauseating hypocrisy of this claim of “American exceptionalism.” I did not watch Obama’s address from the Oval Office Sunday night but I did note in the 11 PM newscast soundbites that he did, indeed, invoke that wretched phrase again to justify his claim that the US has a right to perpetrate its own violence against anyone, anywhere, anytime. What a wretched POTUS this guy has turned out to be!!

  4. Pingback: American culture’s long, passionate relationship with violence | cuprodotme

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s